Coming out way ahead in the nominations round, and then taking 22% of your 3000 votes, Benefit They’re Real is your choice for Best Mascara.

You praised Benefit’s They’re Real for its refusal to clump, smear, or smudge, its great brush, and of course, how good it makes your eyes look.


Of course, one mascara can’t be the perfect mascara for everyone, so be sure to check out the great list of top contenders if They’re Real isn’t right for you.

Further Reading:

Seven Best Lip Balms

Commerce covers the best products on Kinja Gear, finds you deals on those products on Kinja Deals, and asks you about your favorites on Kinja Co-Op, click here to learn more. We operate independently of Editorial and Advertising, and if you buy something through our posts, we may get a small share of the sale. We want your feedback.